So thennnn, I discovered these, at Forever 21! Normally Forever 21 heels are also freakishly tall for me, but these are labeled as medium heels with 3.5" heel height. They have two color options, Beige or Gray. This pair is surprisingly comfortable and I've wore it to work a few times already without too much problem. Here is the link if you are interested in getting them.
Also at Target.com, I got a pair of brown Oxfords. I am actually not too much of a big fan of these Oxford shoes. But I got them anyway because I wanted to get up to $50 total for free shipping, LOL. I originally thought I was going to return these, but once I put them on, I didn't want to anymore :) They actually don't look bad at all on (looks good with skirt too) and are comfortable enough to walk around in for the whole day.
Also got this pair for my best friend's wedding in December. Even though the heels look high, but the platform and the strap around the ankle help tremendously.
I also grabbed this pair of super adorable flats from Target store when it was on clearance. I actually originally saw this pair in the store a few months ago and wanted them, but couldn't find a pair in my size. When I shopped online, I again looked for them but unfortunately they were out of stock. So imagine my excitement when I found a pair of size 7 in another Target store, with a red clearance tag a few weeks ago! These are my favorite pair of flats to wear now.